Who is more powerful, a high court judge or a chief minister?

Asked 27-Sep-2022
Viewed 196 times

1 Answer


The age-old question of who is more powerful, a high court judge or a chief minister, is one that has been debated for many years. There are many factors to consider when trying to answer this question, and no one definitive answer. 

In India, the chief minister is the head of government of each state. They are responsible for the day-to-day running of the state, and report directly to the president of India. The chief minister is also responsible for ensuring that the state legislature and the state executive are functioning smoothly. The high court judge, on the other hand, is a member of the judiciary. They are responsible for interpreting the law and delivering justice. They are also responsible for ensuring that the law is followed by all citizens of the state.

Our country believes in a federal system of government, so power is divided into three branches: legislative, executive, and judicial.
That, while the executive power of the state is constitutionally vested in the governor, it shall be exercised by him either directly or through officers subordinate to him in accordance with our constitution.
However, the truth is reversed. Executive power is vested in the chief minister and his council of ministers, and the chief minister has broad authority to make rules, regulations, policies, and ordinances while keeping the welfare of the state in mind.

Indeed, the main power is concentrated in the hands of executive bodies because the implementation of legislative rules is primarily dependent on how the executive wings of the government respond.
Without a doubt, high court judges are the most prestigious and honourable position in our country because they enjoy a high status and honour in society. He also receives high-level official benefits.
A high court judge also has broad authority to summon the chief secretary of the state for an explanation of any legal issues in order to protect our constitution. A high court judge has the authority to overturn a government rule if it is found to be unconstitutional or not passed in accordance with the law.
On the other hand, the executive bodies, by failing to obey the orders of the honourable judge in a timely and appropriate manner, force him to state that his power is limited.
To summarise, a chief minister's powers are far greater, and thus a chief minister of a state is more powerful than a high court judge.