Can a private virtual method be overridden?

Asked 06-Dec-2019
Updated 04-Sep-2023
Viewed 564 times

1 Answer


0

No, a private virtual methodcannot be overridden in most object-oriented programming languages, including C++, C#, and Java. The reason for this limitation lies in the access control and visibility rules associated with methods in these languages.

In object-oriented programming, methods are often categorized into different access levels, such as public, protected, private, and sometimes package-private (default). These access modifiers determine where and how methods can be accessed or inherited by subclasses.

1. Public Methods: These methods are accessible from anywhere and can be overridden by subclasses. They are part of the class's public interface.

2. Protected Methods: Protected methods are accessible within the class and by its subclasses. Subclasses can override them.

3. Private Methods: Private methods are only accessible within the class that defines them. They are not visible to subclasses or external code, which means they cannot be overridden.

A virtual method is typically marked with a keyword like `virtual` in C++ or `virtual` and `override` in C#. These keywords signal the intention to allow subclasses to provide their own implementations of the method. However, the ability to override a method depends on its visibility:

  • Public and Protected Virtual Methods: These can be overridden by subclasses, allowing for polymorphism, where different subclasses provide specialized implementations of the same method.
  • Private Virtual Methods: Since private methods are not visible to subclasses, they cannot be overridden. Attempting to override a private virtual method in a subclass will result in a compile-time error or be treated as a separate, non-overriding method.

In summary, private virtual methods are a contradiction in terms in most object-oriented programming languages because they combine an access level (private) that restricts visibility to the defining class with a modifier (virtual) that implies the method is designed for subclass customization. Therefore, it's essential to choose the appropriate access level for methods when designing classes to enable or restrict inheritance and method overriding as needed.