What was a drawback of the U S. Bracero Program?

Asked 27-Oct-2018
Viewed 304 times

1 Answer


0

The U.S. Bracero Program of 1942-1964 was a labor agreement between the U.S. and Mexico that allowed for the temporary admission of Mexican workers to the U.S. for agricultural and railroad labor. It was intended to be a mutually beneficial agreement, providing U.S. employers with a steady supply of labor and granting Mexican workers an opportunity to work in the U.S. and send earnings back home. Despite its goal of being mutually beneficial, the U.S. Bracero Program had a number of drawbacks.

  • One of the primary drawbacks of the U.S. Bracero Program was its failure to protect the rights of Mexican workers. The agreement was intended to provide workers with certain protections, including a guaranteed minimum wage, safe working conditions, and limits on hours and working days. In practice, however, employers often failed to adhere to the agreement, and workers were frequently exploited. Mexican workers were not always paid the wage they were promised, and they were often subject to dangerous working conditions, such as exposure to pesticides. Furthermore, the program lacked any meaningful enforcement of its labor standards, making it difficult for workers to hold employers accountable.
What was a drawback of the U S Bracero Program
  • Furthermore, there were also numerous reports of fraud and abuse of the guest workers. Many employers withheld wages and treated the workers inhumanely, leading to widespread exploitation. Additionally, there were cases of human trafficking and smuggling, as some workers were essentially 'bought' and brought to the United States without the proper documentation or authorization.
  • The U.S. Bracero Program also had a negative impact on the wages of U.S. citizens. The agreement allowed employers to hire Mexican workers in place of U.S. citizens, which caused the wages of U.S. citizens to decline. This was especially true in areas with a large number of Mexican workers, such as California and Texas. The influx of lower-paid Mexican workers caused wages for U.S. citizens in these areas to decline significantly.
  • Finally, the U.S. Bracero Program had a significant impact on the U.S. immigration system. The agreement was intended to be a temporary solution to a labor shortage, but it resulted in a large number of Mexican workers entering the U.S. without authorization. This influx of unauthorized immigrants led to the development of a complex and often unfair immigration system that continues to be a major problem in the U.S. today.

Overall, the U.S. Bracero Program was intended to be a mutually beneficial agreement, but it ultimately had a number of drawbacks. It failed to protect the rights of Mexican workers, caused wages for U.S. citizens to decline, and had a significant impact on the U.S. immigration system. For these reasons, the U.S. Bracero Program is often viewed as a failure today.